Salam Sejahtera,
Saya ada membuat penterjemahan dokumen - dokumen bagi urusan rasmi atau tidak rasmi. Seperti surat beranak, sijil nikah dan lain - lain. Dokumen yang telah diterjemah is certified by Jurubahasa Mahkamah.
Juga membuat transcribing untuk minit mesyuarat, prosiding mahkamah, audio dan video dan lain - lain.
I am able to provide translating services for translation of document for official or non official use. Such as Birth Certificate, Marriage Certificate and others. Translated documents are certified by a Court Interpreter. I also offer transcribing services for minutes of meeting, court proceedings, audio and video and others.
For further information, please feel free to contact me at:
Untuk maklumat lanjut, boleh hubungi saya di:
018-2500432 - Whatsapp / Call
016-7026702 - Call / SMS
Irna
Wednesday, September 6, 2017
Monday, July 7, 2014
Introduction to guidance and counselling
INTRODUCTION
What is counselling?
Counselling derived from
the word ‘counsel’. However in recent years, the word acquired its own specific
meaning or technical term to describe a therapeutic interaction between two
people or more.
All of us, maybe at some
point of our time, find ourselves acting as counsellor. Most of us do not have
a true grasp on what are the concepts of counselling or how to play the role as
a professional counsellor.
Professional counsellors
are highly trained and able to use different kinds of counselling theories and
approaches to help their clients. It is a big different to a person who uses
some counselling skills as a role for example a colleague or a friend.
Counselling is sometimes a
complex and confusing term. It carries different meanings for different people.
In the Concise Oxford Dictionary, there are two definitions of counselling:
1)
“to give advice to (a person) on social or personal problems,
especially professionally.”
2)
“the process of assisting and guiding clients especially by a
trained person on a professional basis, to resolve especially personal, social
or psychological problems and difficulties”
From the two meanings
stated above, it appears to be quite conflicting, thus adding to potential
confusion.
So, to define it clearly,
counselling is :
§ A process when a
counsellor and a client make time in order to help review and explore the
client, emotional or stressful feelings.
§ It is an act of helping
the client to view things from a different point of view and clearly. As a
result, clients will be able to focus on their own feelings.
§ To develop a relationship
through trust. The most important thing to counselling is confidentiality.
However it is by law that a counsellor needs to disclose information if they
believe that there is a risk to life.
What counselling is not :
§ Being judgemental
§ Giving advice
§ Sorting out problems for
the client
§ Emotionally involve with
the client
§ Looking at clients problem
from your own point of view.
OBJECTIVES OF COUNSELLING
The main objective of
counselling is to help the client to recognise and clarify their problem. These
problems may vary and also could be many. These people come from different
types of background and educations. It may appear superficial but it may be
deeper and have implications.
As well as trying to solve
the presenting problem, the client will may need to come to terms with the situation
in which the client finds or to want to seek a better adjustment. This is much
more difficult to face, because for most people they secretly hope for some magic
to make the difficulty go away and there is nothing magic about counselling. If
the aim is adjustable then it could be a long term process for both the
counsellor and the client unable to see any immediate results. One of the
points which the counsellor must make clear at the beginning is that he/she is
unable to change the practicalities of the situation.
Another main objective is
to be able to help the client to bring out voluntary changes for and by
themselves. And when undergoing the counselling experience, they are lead to
try to go deeper inside them. This will enable the client to retain or gain
self-dependence. The factor which is common to all forms of counselling is that
it takes place within a relationship and interaction between counsellor and
client which is the most important component.
COUNSELLING GOALS
“ ..in behavioural terms,
3 categories of behavioural can be identified, namely altering maladaptive
behaviour, learning the decision – making process and preventing problems..”
(Krumboltz,
1966)
Goals of counselling are
described as immediate, mediate or process goals and long range. Goal
statements are important and a must, because it provides direction and purpose
of the counselling session. A counsellor’s goal is to understand his client’s feelings,
motivations and behaviour. There are several goals with different functions.
§ Immediate goals – it is
the process of self-exploration and to motivate the client to go through the
counselling process until the mediate or process goals are achieved, and client
needs to understand himself, vis-à-vis his environmental constraints and
personal resource.
§ Process goal is what the
client will go through to realize the ultimate goal of self – realization, self
– actualization and self – understanding.
§ Long term goals are to
make or turn the client into a ‘fully functioning person’
There are also several
major goals that I would like to achieve with Anthony :
1)
Achievement of positive mental health.
·
If he could reach a positive mental health, he could adjust
and response positively towards other people or any situation.
2)
Resolution of problems.
·
To resolve Anthony’s problem that were brought to my
attention. This is important as an outcome of the former goal to imply positive
mental health.
3)
Improving personal effectiveness
·
This is for Anthony to preserve a good mental health and
securing desirable behaviour changes and personal development
4)
To help change
·
To maximize his individual freedom to choose and act within
the conditions wanted by the environment and society
5)
Decision making
·
To enable him to make good decisions. This is to foster
personal growth. I will need to help him clarify his personal goals
6)
Behaviour modification
·
To remove Anthony’s undesirable behaviour and to stress on
the development of his potential within himself.
Research on the situation given
It is essential that
before each counselling session, the counsellor must make sure that the client
is comfortable. The reason being is that, the client will be able to express
himself and not shy away.
Because Anthony does not
understand why he had to go for counselling, I will need to explain to him and
make him comfortable.
Therefore, before a
counselling session starts, I would do a little research on the client. The
reason is:
1)
To get to know the
client and to make him feel comfortable so that he could freely express
himself.
2)
To understand what are the factors that made him behave this
way.
3)
To learn what other effects there is towards himself and also
his behaviour.
4)
To share with the client ways that would help to express his
feelings and emotion during the session.
This mini research is
important for me to get a clearer picture on what the client is going through.
It could also enlighten the parents, siblings and people around the client on
how to understand the client better. So, with that knowledge, they could also
help to correct and improvise the client’s problematic behaviour. The goal is
also for Anthony to be honest and to make changes in his life, for him to
understand and know that this behaviour is wrong and could have dire
consequences if he continues acting like this. The aim is for him to want to
change on his own, for himself and his future.
I would then prepare a set
of questions that I would want to ask the client during our session.
1)
Introduction questions
§ Questions pertaining to
his full name, age, date of birth, hobbies and other questions that will help
me get to know a little bit on his background.
2)
Building a relationship
§ Question that I would put
to him in order for me to gain his trust in me so that he would not shy away
and feel reluctant and or uncomfortable. For example, “how are you today?”,
have you had your lunch?”, “I heard that you like to play video games, what
kind of video games?”.
At the same time,
observations are done towards the client. On how he react to each questions, or
how he is reacting. Nervous?, oblivious?, confused?, afraid? Or anxious?.
The next step would be is
to start an exploration. This step is to understand the problem of the client’s
behaviour through his perspective, so that we could apply the appropriate
theories in order to help the client.
What are counselling theories?
Counsellors use
counselling theories as treatment plan in treating their clients. There are a
lot of counselling theories that they can refer too. Some of them are Gestalt,
Behavioural, Jungian, Family System, Constructivist, cognitive and many more.
During a session,
counsellors would apply several theories to help the client because there is no
one size fits all theory or strategies that could be applied to all
circumstances.
After the assessment that
I had made earlier with Anthony, I have some thoughts that perhaps Anthony is
having trouble with coping with his parent’s divorce. He wants the proper
attention from his parents, which is why he is behaving like the way he is now.
I have come up with several theories in order to help him overcome his
problems.
Theories
that I would apply
Individual psychology (Alfred
Adler)
1) The
main reason of a personality development is not the unconscious behaviour but
their conscious behaviour. Therefore,
the Alderian theory emphasizes on personal responsibility on how a person will
choose to adjust to any situation or a life event and how they interpret them.
2) Adler
also view that we try hard to be successful and along the way, we overcome some
areas that makes us inferior. He refer this phase as our personal growth
towards our goal for perfection. So for people who did not succeed in
overcoming their feelings of inferiority will then develop an inferiority
complex.
3) In
this Adlerian theory, a person might choose the kind of behaviour as a result
of their lack of interest in social or personal growth. A person when are
discouraged when they attempt of making good behaviour had failed to get the
needed results leads to misbehaviours. The best antidote is to encourage their
good behaviour.
4) Early
education starts at home, it is the basic socialization for a child. A child
interpretation of things happening in their life is determined by their
interaction with their family members. Through this interaction, children are
taught on how to accept and interpret events through certain evaluations of
themselves and their surrounding environment. These perceptions are called
fictions. Basic mistakes could be made when it is based on fictions. As for
Anthony’s case, those mistakes are perhaps :
i)
Minimization or denial of one’s
worth results in the individual believing that they cannot be successful in
life.
ii)
Life took over courage and
therefore he is willing to take risks without knowing the outcome.
Intervention strategies
Strategies
that I would take via the Adlerian theory is :
§
To establish rapport
- To
explore his conscious thoughts, logic and beliefs on what sort of his
behaviours that is not within his best and social interests.
- helping
him to gain insight and for him to define his lifestyle
§
Encouragement
- Supporting
him by telling him that I believe that he has the ability to be responsible and
change his behaviour. Therapy is cognitive and also emphasizing on the faulty
logic to encourage him to take responsibility to change
- To
promote a relationship with Anthony as an equal one, with us sharing
impressions, insights, opinions and feelings to promote therapeutic
relationship.
§
Confrontation
- Challenging
his behaviour and private logic.
§
Task setting
- Ask
him to behave as if he is who he wanted to be and provides him with ‘homework’
outside of the session
- Help
him set up short term goals that will head to long term goals.
§
Asking the ‘Questions’, such as :
- “How
would your life would be if you are doing well?” or
- “Don’t
you want to be successful?”
§
‘Spitting
in his soup’
- To
point out to him why he is actually behaving this way. And should after that he
continues with his current behaviour, but he cannot do so, because he is
already made aware of his motivation for engaging in that behaviour.
Goals to achieve through this
theory
§
To focus on helping Anthony to develop
a healthy lifestyle and social interest.
§
To assist him through 4 goals of
the therapeutic process by :
- Establishing
the therapeutic relationship
- Examining
his lifestyle
- To
develop his insights
- To
change his behaviour
Person centered (Carl Rogers)
This theory views human
basically as good. Carl Rogers believed that if given the proper treatment of
empathy, acceptance and warmth, people would move to change.
Intervention strategies
§
To set up an environment where Anthony could explore any
aspect of himself safely.
§
To facilitate this exploration with empathy, positive regard
and warmth.
§
By using Q-Sort to assess.
-
100 different self-descriptions are written on a card.
-
Ask Anthony to sort them into 9 piles from a scale of ‘most
like me’ to ‘least like me’.
-
The stacks are then recorded.
-
Cards are re – sort again by Anthony into how he would like
it to be like.
-
This Q-Sort will give the indications of the incongruence
between his perceived real self and ideal self.
§ To help him through his
real reflections of feelings by keeping him focused on the clarifications of
feelings and information. To use open-ended questions to help him gain insight
into experiences and do necessary changes in life.
Goals to achieve through this
theory
To
facilitate Anthony to :
- Realistic self – perception
- To have greater confidence
- To have the sense of positive warmth
- To have better social skills and adaptive behaviour
- To be fully thinking in all kinds of aspects in life
Behavioural theory (B.F. Skinner)
Skinner
believes that adaptive behaviour can be learned. This theory has a here and now
focus. One of the process is social modelling, whereby client can learn new
behaviour by watching other people rather than having them to engage in that
behaviour and experience consequences.
Intervention strategies
- To not just maintain my role as a counsellor but can vary and act as
a facilitator, reinforce or as a consultant
- To be active and to supervise other people that are within Anthony’s
environments to ensure he achieve his goals. In this case, the divorced
parents.
- To give punishment. This is to deliver stimuli to achieve
elimination of unwanted behaviour as a result.
- Behaviour rehearsals – by repeating and improving his behaviour
until the desired behaviour is accomplished.
Goals to achieve through this
theory
To
achieve Anthony’s life through better adjustments of his life and therefore
achieving his personal goals professionally and or personally.
Reality therapy (William Glasser)
Glasser
believes that human being is a long process and therefore along that, one’s
personality will change at any time by learning on what he needs from what he
sees. He also believes that humans are self – determined. Every person has a
perception about themselves.
Intervention strategies
- To act like a teacher and be a model for Anthony.
- To create a warm environment of acceptance so that he culd focus on
controlling his display of thoughts and actions.
- To show the reality of his behaviour, is unrealistic.
- By using confrontations for him to accept responsibilities of his
act.
- By using humour to point out absurdity without being sarcastic.
Goals to achieve through this
theory
- To help Anthony to become rational and psychologically strong. A
strong and rational person can behave responsibly towards himself and
other people.
- To determine what he wants in life.
- Develop a practical plan for Anthony to accomplish his desires and
needs.
- Helping him to put his past behind and to focus on the present.
- To accept no excuses and to have him eliminate self-punishment from
his life.
Conclusion
Counselling is no magical
solution. Most of us tend to view it as problem resolution, to emphasize goals
or as tension reduction. Counselling is generative in terms of spirit and
essence. Its aim is assisting individual to develop themselves so that he will
become psychologically mature and are capable of realising his potentials.
Through the several theories adopted above, t might help Anthony to resolve his
behaviour into a behaviour accepted by society. All of the theories above have
the same motive and objective, to help Anthony or any other person with
problems like Anthony to gain insight within themselves so that they will be
able to maximized their potentiality and opportunities that he have, present or
in the coming future. And as a result, to become self-actualized,
self-sufficient and self-directed.
REFERENCES
v Types of counselling theories,
viewed at http://www.edb.utexas.edu/faculty/rochlen/TheoriesApp/index.html
accessed on 11th Nov 2013.
v
How
to Use Counseling Theories & Techniques for School Counseling,
viewed at http://www.ehow.com/how_6858434_use-theories-techniques-school-counseling.html accessed on 10th
Nov 2013
v S.Narayana Rao-
Counselling and Guidance,Second edition, (1997)Tata McGraw –Hill Publishing
Company Limited.NewDelhi.(Pg:63-68)
v Cognitive and behavioural
therapy, viewed at http://www.counselling-directory.org.uk/behavioural.html
acccessed on 13th Nov 2013.
Writing in ESL
In this essay, I will
explore on different writing activities and writing feedback that would suit
each of the 4 categories of student interest, as recognised by Lipstein &
Renninger, and how their research, could be generalized for our own ESL
students.
Introduction
Even though it is every
teacher’s dream, to see all of their students becoming interested writers, but
it didn’t occur to us that we can teach them to ‘love’ writing. But instead we
chose to see interest in writing as something that a person was born with.
Although interest plays a large role in motivation and confidence, we need a
clearer misunderstanding of how teachers and classroom practices can influence student’s
interest for the act of writing. Rebecca L. Lipstein and K. Ann Renninger
studied the perceptions of 178 students in grades 7, 8 and 9 to develop this
understanding. As a result, they had offer characteristics of students in four
phases of interest and describe instructional approaches to meet students wants
and needs.
Why does interest matters?
John Dewey (1913) explains
that students that are interested in a subject will have more confident about
their work in relation to that subject. Therefore it is effortless for them.
A person’s interest is
said to the most powerful tool in learning. Because, interest can influence
attention, goals and levels of learning.
“Even though interest has been recognized as an important
condition for learning, educators continue to wrestle with the difficulties of
working with academically unmotivated students”
(Hidi & Harackiewic, 2000)
Teachers didn’t know on
how their role could help the students to flourish their interest. It is
because that teacher’s often have thoughts that whether the students are
interested or not, that they might miss to recognize that they could contribute
in developing the student’s interest. A teacher’s dream is to see their
students have interests in writing and becoming a good writer. But in reality,
we find only few of our students with these traits.
As for writing, having an
interest definitely affects the way how the students approach writing and the
results that they receive.
“Research on writing and motivation indicates that students
who have an interest for writing are more likely to set affective goals, make
use of helpful strategies, and seek feedback as they work with writing tasks”
(Lipstein & Renninger, 2007)
Suitable writing strategy for each category of students.
Phase one students
Phase one students are
students that are in primary school. These students are more likely to describe
writing as ‘boring’ and needs a lo0t of work. Usually they are confused on how
do they approach the task.
What they wants
§ Phase one students wants
teachers to understand how writing is something that is hard for them to do.
§ They want writing to feel
easier for them. Something they would enjoy and not hard work.
What they need
Teachers play the role of
facilitating what the student wants. Teachers will need to facilitate them in
receiving concrete suggestions and strategies for them to write.
Writing activities that could be done
1)
Creating sentence completion
§ Provide a worksheet that
has a word written on it. For example, ‘Apples, Apples.
§ Ask them to write simple
sentences to describe the word
Why?
§ Students can relate the
words with what they know. So the task will not be a burden to them.
§ Students could trace the
beginning part of the sentence and just add one or two more sentences to
describe the word.
§ Students could build their
grammar
2)
Create an organized and detailed writing prompts (this
involves 4 worksheets)
§ 1st worksheet
-
Give a worksheet with unfinished sentence. For example ;
‘When I grow up I want to be .’
§ 2nd worksheet
-
This worksheet will have an instruction. For example ; Let’s
say the student wants to be a scientist. The instruction would be ‘What will I
do if I want to be a scientist?’
-
Ask them to fill up the box with simple words explaining on
what they will do if they want to become a scientist.
§ 3rd worksheet
-
Prepare the worksheet for sentence completion. For example ;
‘When I grow up, I want to be a scientist
-
Provide 2 boxes in the worksheet and label them :
-
Box 1 – ‘First I need to do .’
-
Box 2 – Then, I will .’
-
Ask the students to fill up those 2 boxes in simple words /
sentences.
§ 4th worksheet
-
Give a blank piece of worksheet, have the students to join
the words that they had provided to build up sentences.
-
During this exercise, teachers will need to walk them through
it and have them help each other.
Why?
§ Students will know how to
organize their writing, by which comes first method
§ They will be able to make
up sentences by joining them together
§ Its fun and not
pressuring, they will constantly have to use their imagination to make up words
to complete their writing.
Phase two students
What they want
Phase 2 students already
have the basics on how to write. At this phase they like getting feedback from
the teachers. They take writing is to be done in order to please the teachers
and getting back compliments / feedback.
What they need
These students have this
impression of that the right way to do it is the teacher’s way. They need to be
taught and encouraged to have their own say in their writing.
Writing activities that could be done
1)
Creative story writing
The teacher could either give them a topic or let them choose a topic on
their own. Have them construct a story. During this session, the teacher will
facilitate them on how they should write their stories, giving suggestion for
them to ponder on or why they had chosen that particular topic. Have them give
ideas to each other, while the teacher gives comments or feedback about those
ideas.
Why?
§ Promotes creative writing
§ During the session, the teachers
will facilitate, they like getting feedbacks on the article that they are
currently doing, from what the teacher comments on, they improvise.
§ With active interactions
between teachers and students during the sessions and getting instant feedback
at the same time, they will put in extra effort, effortlessly.
Phase Three students
What they want
Students in this phase
loves writing and consider it as a place where they can go and be free. It is
fun for them because they get to make their own rule on what they wanted to
write. And because they like writing they would revise and will gladly spends
more time on writing. They do not prefer feedback and peer conferencing on
telling them how to write.
What they need
To encourage them to write
and to channel their enthusiasm and to broaden their awareness of writing
conventions and audience expectations.
Writing activities that could be done
Because of their need to
express themselves through their ideas, this kind of activity would suit them.
In this phase, the students already know the different types of writing that
they need to use when they are given a topic to write. (narrative, persuasive
or expository).
§ Find an article for them
to express their ideas. For example; write an expository essay on the topic ‘Heavier
punishments for traffic offenders.’
§ Have them explain reasons
to support this topic. Use several examples to support that reason.
Why?
§ As they love to express
themselves in writing, by providing a topic and let them write it however they
want it, could encourage them more.
§ They don’t mind the extra
revision that they need to do, and by doing research ti expands their ideas.
§ They could read aloud
their essays and take part in a teacher – guided discussions to defend their
own point of view.
Phase Four students
What they want?
In this phase, the
students wants to please audiences and themselves by showing balance between
their personal standards to a more widely accepted standards of good writing.
What they need
They need to continuously
be challenged in order to improve and they want and do not mind receiving
constructive feedback about their writing.
Writing
activities that could be done
Research writing
§ The objective is to help
the students incorporate sources in their essay
§ Why we use sources?
§ They will need to do some
research as a way to sort out different reasons.
§ Facilitators need to
emphasize that in order to prove that the ‘thesis’ is correct, they will need
to go beyond and research all ideas.
§ Let the students look at
the author’s use of sources. Asking some possible questions along with it. For
example ; ‘What do quotes do?’, ‘How does the author use the quote?’, ‘What is
the balance between the quotes and the author’s own voice?’
§ Outline to the students
what are the ideal structures for quotes.
§ Break them into small
groups and have them discuss from each other’s papers
§ Write out their essays.
Why?
§ As they do not mind peer
conferencing, it will help them construct and improvise.
§ A more detailed topic was
given because they are already good writers. And from that detailed topic, they
will need to do a lot of revising as their writings will then be presented to
audiences.
Suitable writing feedback
Phase one students – Indicidualised feedback
As they are not good in
writing, they are a bit confused on how to approach the task. So, an
individualised feedback is the best because they want a concrete suggestion
type of feedback from the teachers, to tell them whether they are doing it
correctly in a constructive manner. So, the suggestions are manageable and
easier for them to digest, thus making the writing feels easier.
Phase Two students – Individualized feedback
These students most likely
will accept suggestion given to them without any questions. And if they
completely accept those suggestions, it could not progress them to be a good
writer. Those suggestions could be posed as questions, such as,
‘What if ….?’
‘Why did you choose
these?’
‘What did you choose
these?’
‘What are you trying to
state in the paragraph here ….. is that what you mean?’
By posing the suggestions
as questions, it will make them think of other options that they can use.
Phase Three students – Individualized feedback
The problem here is for
the teachers to give feedback without dismissing as contrary or intrusive to
their way.
Feedback could be given
through audience response. It is due to their desire to impress an audience. For example ;
‘Could you make the point
clear to me, because I am not sure what
you mean?’
With this type of comments,
these students most likely won’t dismiss it. The reason being is that these
comments do not state negative comments about their writing.
Phase Four student – Individualized feedback and peer
conferencing
Individualized feedback
It is important for comments
or suggestions to be balanced. Adding in constructive suggestions, for their
improvement. Reason is, it challenges them and help them grow as good writers.
Peer – conferencing
Constructive comments
given by peers could help them realise what are other ideas that other people
might have. Therefore by comparing their writing to their peers, they could
stretch their writing in order to improve.
During the process of
doing this assignment, I had read a few online journals and e-books that I
found on the internet, regarding Lipstein & Renninger’s research. I am not
an ESL teacher currently, but I can relate their findings to what I experienced
during my school years. I still can recall on how I hate writing. But, from the
activities that were used by my teachers to grab our attention and help us
write, makes writing seems like we are not doing writing, compositions and sort
at all. At the same time, we would actively participate in giving or voicing
out our opinions and putting it into words. And at the end of the day, voila!
We had written something.
If I were to ask from the
point of view of an ESL teacher, I think that Lipstein & Renninger had
helped all teachers by summarizing the phases of students and by what they
prefer and don’t prefer. So, teachers could start building their lesson plans
from there. According to types of phases that the students are categorized in.
It is important for all
teachers to know the strength of their students. It will make activities be
done much easier. 2 things could be accomplished, the student understands what
they are learning because the teachers does not only teach but facilitates them
on what they need. Teaches on the other hand achieved their teaching goals.
What I understand from
their work also, is that to teach writing to student is age – related. Most
important thing is interest. Because according to them, interest for writing
affects the ways that students approach writing and the results they achieve.
To have them be interested in writing is the first step to sculpt a good
writer.
Student wants to be heard.
So, by facilitating their needs according to the phases, it will deepen their
interest for writing.
“It is worth noting that the needs of students in one phase
becomes the wants of students in the next phase.”
(Lipstein & Renninger)
Therefore, by noting their
needs, students will then develop more interest in writing, enjoying what was
once hard for them.
Also, in their research,
they had provide, the proper ‘what kind of feedbacks’ on student’s paper,
according to their phases.
We cannot use only certain
kind of feedback for all of the students. Certain phases might use or need more
than 1 type of feedback in order for them to be a strong writers.
Advantages of peer – conferencing
Lipstein & Renninger
spoke about peer – conferencing in their work. It is a successful ambition,
students could learn a lot not just about what are their strength and
weaknesses, but also how and what it takes to make a good story.
But not all phases likes
peer – conferencing. Because to them, at that stage they don’t like to be
criticise especially by someone whom they think who is not superior enough to
be commenting their work.
But at certain phases,
peer – conferencing are needed and could be useful because it helps them see their work from other people points
of view, not just one particular person.
There are many pros and
cons of peer – conferencing, and every pros will have its cons.
The pros of peer
conferencing are we get to view our own writing from other people’s
perspective. From there we would know what did we do wrong, how do we correct
it and so on. Peer conferencing is good because we get to share ideas with
other people. No one can say the same thing as someone else; therefore, we get
wide variety of opinions.
Furthermore, I do believe
that the more students are actively engaged in something, the more and the
better they learn. Through peer conferencing students takes an active role,
because all these times, teachers and students worked in an isolated
environment. A situation where students write and teacher’s grade. Therefore,
students missed out on an opportunity to learn from each other, having
conversations about their writing and read more. So, by having student
participates in peer conferencing, they will take interest at other’s writing.
Also a root for them, when they receive back their essays from their teacher’s.
Promoting peer
conferencing will have the students understand that they are not being lectured
to but they can teach each other. Students must know what is wrong before
having to correct it. Therefore by viewing their peers work, the more they
could learn and apply that knowledge to their own writing. They train their
eyes to spot the mistakes, so that they won’t repeat that same mistakes.
Lastly, the pros of peer
conferencing are less paperwork for teachers. When peers edited their work,
teachers could concentrate more on the students.
Disadvantages of peer conferencing
Peer conferencing has no
grading system on the qualities of peer review. Different journals have
different sets of standards. We would not know the reviewer’s quality and
expertise.
There might be chances
that a good writing could get rejected, whilst a poor writing could easily
pass. Because, maybe writing are judged whether the other peer likes them or
not, rather than the results of the writing.
Students don’t really know
how to evaluate writings. Perhaps more on minor, mundane mistakes, for example;
grammar and punctuation mistakes rather than the content.
Having students to judge
their peer’s work could be uneasy. Resulting to them not giving honest
comments.
Can Lipstein & Renninger research be generalized.
After reading through
their work, I would suggest their theories can and should be generalized.
Because, we would just focus on the needs that they had stated, and enhance
student’s interest in writing rather than making them feel like it’s a burden.
Therefore, understanding of the student’s characteristic according to their
phases could really help teachers.
By learning writing,
students enhance their skills in grammar, spellings and learning new words, in
their way as how they want it to be. Provided that lesson plans be carried out
effectively, the results would be amazing.
Conclusion
I concluded that, and we
all know that to educate people is a tedious process. Everyone has their own
sets of mind and their own way of thinking. But in an overall manner, in
writing, each phase of students has their own ways on how they need their
lessons be taught to them. it is important for teachers to listen to their
students need, to make them be successful and achieve the satisfaction of being
a good educator.
REFERENCES
v
5 reasons student should
be doing peer editing, viewed at http://secondarysolutionsblog.com/5-reasons-students-should-be-doing-more-peer-editing/
accessed on 12th Nov 2013.
v
Renninger, K. Ann, (2009)'Interest and Identity Development in
Instruction: An Inductive Model',
Educational Psychologist, 44:2, 105 — 118
v Rebecca L. Lipstein and K.
Ann Renninger (2007), Interest for
Writing: How Teachers Can Make a Difference, The English Journal, Vol. 96,
No. 4 (Mar., 2007), pp. 79-85,
vEngaging students in the writing process, viewed at http://engagingstudentminds.wordpress.com/author/bethanyalder/
accessed on 12th Nov 2013.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)